First off, I didn't mean the normal public challenge, I posted a public challenge to them both on the fighters board, so it would stand the test of time for others to see.
I offered them both a best ouf of 3 match, loser loses a guildskill down to apprentice. As you can look back, there was no response.
Both of these rangers are considerably bigger than I am.
Secondly, you cannot issue the normal challenges without the other individual being in the land, period.
Written by my hand on the 5th of Hindyear, in the year 1147.