In thinking about the possibility of trying to come up with some kind of universally agreed-upon guideline for the use of charming... as you suggest a Constitution of Charming, naturally I would love to see some kind of judiciousness applied here. Howe

ver, in my past efforts at trying to negotiate with others here, I have found that there are so many competing interests in any given situation, it is virtually impossible to reach a consensus about anything. Also, even if we did develop some set of \"

rules\" about this, how would they be enforced? Would we then have to set up some kind of overseeing mechanism to ensure that everyone was being true to our agreement? Personally, I don't have the time to review every use of non-mage, non-LM charming t

hat happens in Avalon. I feel that although many might approach this with good intentions, many others would skirt the rules and a black market of such items would naturally arise. I can't see there being any way to really control the use of such item

s.

Written by my hand on the 15th of Midsummer, in the year 1059.